How about similar to CGS style. Under the navigation and header there was a strip with players' images and separated by game with small text underneath the image for alias. Something like that could be a very simple option. But in my opinion, there is really no need for more than your starting 5 unless you are a community or don't really have a set starting 5. I am guilty of doing more than 5 on my site, but my teams are very unorganized(which I hate).